Transferable Empathy

Writing fiction, for me, comes down to how well I can empathize with someone. This someone is usually a character I've created, for good or for evil, for humorous or serious purposes. Readers can often sense when you, as author, don't especially like a character you've written, and that's fine. In the world of fiction every hero needs a baddy to fight, and every beaten dog needs an asshole owner who likes to pounce it off a wall or two.

What's not so fine is if your reader senses you've created this jerkoff character with absolutely no understanding, or empathy, for what makes the jerk the way he is. If you don't know your jerk throws his dog around because he was mistreated as a child, or a pack of wild dogs devoured his family on a car trip to Ottawa, then what you've created here is a Straw Character, Easily Blown Away By Any Puff of scrutiny that Happens to Come Along. Why does he have a glass eye? A hook for a hand? A propensity for touching little boys inappropriately?
But I'm not simply talking about back-story here, or interviewing your character to see what her favorite color is. Only charlatans think a paragraph or thirty pages of back-story truly creates a breathing character (either one or three dimensional). These charlatans may go on to win prizes, and chat with Opera, but deep down good writers know these other writers suck. What you need to be is empathetic, people. You need to understand and feel for the worst, most basic character. That UPS guy who delivers a package to your protagonist, says three words, and saunters off never to be seen again? Maybe he has a rash on his inner thigh. Maybe he squints a lot because he needs specs. Man, wouldn't that suck to have a rash, or squint a lot?

Now, I haven't always been the most empathetic person on the face of the earth. Many would say, not even close. But those people are dickheads and I hate them. But I shouldn't hate them, should I? No. Not if I want to put them in a story some day. And the more I write the more other people's minds, and hearts, seem open before me, or at least my imagination. Instead of being totally bored in a room full of people, I find myself actually paying attention on occasion, if only to steal what someone's saying or acting like for my own uses. Now, in my newly acquired state of high empathy. whenever I see a drunk crazy person on the street I wait at least five seconds before turning away, just in case they say something amusing. You see? I'm becoming more empathetic, transferring myself into another person's shoes, so to speak. It's a long, arduous process, to be sure, but a necessary one if you want your characters to seem like a real people your reader might actually meet on the street.

The Jesuit priest Anthony deMello said that no evil can be done in a state of true awareness. So everyday I strive to become more aware of the people I encounter, if only I can write caustic, sweeping generalizations about them later.

32 comments:

Kelly Coyle said...

Why don't you just plumb your psyche like everyone else?

Anonymous said...

I feel nervous about ever seeing you again after all of that Dave....

Geoff Herbach said...

I'd like you to plumb my psyche Dave. That sounds really exciting.

I do think empathy is key in the creation of good characters. Humbert Humperdink or whatever from Lolita? We follow that guy around only because he's human and we don't like him but we feel something for him because of his humanity. If you can't weep for your protagonist (and most everybody he/she encounters), you should probably be working on something else. That's what I think.

Amethyst Vineyard said...

My fiction workshops in high school used to try to make us do those character interviews. I always reminded my teachers that my characters weren't real people, and there was no way they could stop me from making up all the answers, just like I made up the character in the first place. I don't think they appreciated that, and I always ended up having to figure out what my characters' favorite toothpaste was anyway.

Humbert Humbert.

Anonymous said...

I'm glad you're becoming more empathetic Dave.


Even if it is for entirely selfish reasons :-)

And somehow, it's what I imagine King would say about making good characters.

L said...

Engelbert Humperdinck

David Oppegaard said...

I could probably use a good psyche plumb right about now. Of course, every character a writer creates has at least a healthy smattering of the writer's own internal preconceptions added to it, which is pretty much unavoidable. My favorite part about making a character is having them do stuff you'd never do, be it heroic or mettlesome.

Anon, part of my essay was actually mocking the kind of people who always say, "Hey, you should use me in a book." I had a Vietnam vet say that to me just a couple of months ago and I was like hey, I alway wrote about a Vietnam vet, sorry.

Geoff Herbach said...

You know what I feel? Thom Jones singing What's New PussyCat. I want to hug him to my chest and tell him he's going to make it, no problem.

Kelly Coyle said...

He is so hairy.

Dave: when you plumb, make sure you deliver up the gooey bits into a tell-all. That's big these days.

Geoff Herbach said...

Kelly, Our comments got mixed up. Looks like we deleted them at the same time too. I appreciate you letting me know about New v. Up in What's Up Pussy Cat. New is so hopeful. Up just seems vulgar. I don't like the song nearly so much now that I know the truth. I'll spend the rest of the day looking for a different theme song.

Kelly Coyle said...

Except I had it wrong. You had it right. I looked it up.

Kelly Coyle said...

The song and the movie are supposedly based on Warren Beatty's love life, which, I don't know, makes me feel like someone is standing too close behind me in the ticket line for a porn show. If you see what I mean.


What's New, Pussycat?

What's new, pussycat?
Whoa-oh
What's new, pussycat?
Whoa-oh oh

Pussycat pussycat ,
I've got flowers and lots of hours
to spend with you.
So go and power your cute little pussycat nose

Pussycat, pussycat I love you
Yes I do
You and your pussycat nose.

What's new, pussycat?
Whoa-oh
What's new, pussycat?
Whoa-oh oh


Pussycat, pussycat,
You're so thrilling and I'm so willing
to care for you.
So go and make up you big little pussy cat eyes

Pussycat, pussycat, I love you
Yes I do
You and your pussycat eyes.

What's new, pussycat?
Whoa-oh
What's new, pussycat?
Whoa-oh oh

Pussycat, pussycat,
You're delicious and if my wishes
Can all come true,
I'll soon be kissing your sweet little pussycat lips.

Pussycat, pussycat, I love you
Yes I do
You and your pussycat lips.
Whoa-oh
You and your pussycat eyes.
Whoa-oh
You and your pussycat nose.

Geoff Herbach said...

It is sincerely sickening. The innuendo seems much dirtier than Slide it In and Cherry Pie, those great hits of the 80s. I don't want to know so much about Warren Beatty. I agree.

Jeff Smieding said...

Dear Blogagaard,

I concur whole heartedly with your arguments, so much so that I can't help but wonder if you plumbed my psyche all too well as I plumbed the depths of Irish carbombs the other night.

For instance, and I'm really probably giving away a great idea here, I've always fantasized about writing an entire novel from the point of Goon #1, in which we see the heartbreaking circumstances that lead him towards a life of crime, falling in with a den of thieves, and finally meeting an abrupt and untimely end at the end of Dirty Harry's gun, or Batman's fist, or Uma Thurman's Pussy Wagon.

Kelly Coyle said...

Dear Apparition:

The Captain and I are busy derailing this thread. Would you please be courteous and not continue to bring up the original topic?

K

David Oppegaard said...

Don't listen to him, App. You have a great idea there. How about delving intot he life of one of those commander guys Vader was always choking? Wait. That would be fan fiction....

Kelly Coyle said...

Whoa-oh.

Anonymous said...

Real charecters dont self-contradict. i mean, the reader wouldnt look at this charecter and say 'no way can he/she/it do this. it is not a his/her/it thing.'
isnt that right?

i cant write fiction to save my life, i cant make things up. i am so not creative.... i am not sure if it is bad, because then i dont live out my charecters, like captain does. i know i wouldnt be able to detach.

David Oppegaard said...

Anon, Blogagaard fortune cookie say: Creativity is a well, perhaps you must dig deeper to find wellspring of inspiration.

Something dirty said...

Do you think you have an ethical obligation towards people you use in your fiction? I don't think writers should, i guess.

How about the opposite of the Frey think, where an auther takes their experiences and applies a veneer of fiction over it? wouldn't you hate to recognize a distorted version of yourself in something like that?

that's not really what you're talking about.

I have that cat song in my head now! beats the rap song I've had all day: "ya, ya grill. yaya ya grill"

Amethyst Vineyard said...

If anyone ever said to me, "What's new, Pussycat?", even in a friendly, open way, I would punch them in the mouth and then leave them bleeding and crying in the street. It's not right. It's just not done.

Can't characters self-contradict, because people certainly do. All the time.

Anonymous said...

no people dont self contradict. they do the same mistakes over and over, even if it kills them!!!

if you what they are (and not what they pretend to be or you want them to be), you'll see they never self contradict.

Kelly Coyle said...

Anon has some issues.

Geoff Herbach said...

Anon seems fine. Seems to me that the Captain has some issues. Let me consult with Tenille.

David Oppegaard said...

Everyone has issues. My issue this morning: I have to put on pants so I can go to work.

Life is hard. All night I dream I was trying on formal wear.

Kelly Coyle said...

Don't you work behind a counter? Skip the pants.

David Oppegaard said...

workers unite! No pants for everyone!

Amethyst Vineyard said...

You could wear a skirt instead, Op. A fancy skirt with ribbons and bows.

David Oppegaard said...

Yes, and then I'll move to Scottland and eat Haggis and play bagpipes, and it'll be good.

Anonymous said...

I missed the "know" kelly, in "if you KNOW what they are"

Thanks captain!

Thanks Dave, I dont want to write (not now atleast) The thing is that I have imagined at least half the world around me. Right now I want to see things as they are.

I think Kelly is right Captain, I might have some issues.

Kelly Coyle said...

Well, Anon, Dave is right, too. We all have issues. Your earlier post just seemed a little dour, if you see what I mean.

There was this Twilight Zone comic when I was a kid. One of the issues had a story of a couple of girls who, for some reason, wanted to see people as they were. So they bumped into a genie or an alien or something, who granted their wish, and they say that everybody was really these gray bug things.

Kelly Coyle said...

Put "saw" in for "say" there. I'm going to bed now.

Post a Comment